Using MTG proxies in Casual Play

Using MTG proxies in Casual Play

Magic: The Gathering (MTG), a game revered for its complexity and strategic depth, also boasts a vast and diverse card pool. This richness, however, comes with a cost—literally. Many players find themselves priced out of accessing the full spectrum of cards, leading to the utilization of proxies.

Proxies, simply put, are stand-ins for actual MTG cards, used primarily for casual play. But when does their use cross the line from convenience to controversy? This article delves into the legal and ethical aspects of using MTG proxies in casual settings.

Understanding Proxies in MTG

A proxy in MTG is typically a printed or digital representation of a card, not issued by Wizards of the Coast (WotC), the game's publisher. These can range from simple handwritten notes to high-quality prints. Their primary purpose is to replicate the function of an actual card in gameplay, often used when the original is unavailable or unaffordable.

MTG proxies

Legal Perspective

Legally, WotC's stance is clear: proxies are not legal for use in official tournaments or sanctioned events. This is to maintain the integrity of the game and its economy. However, WotC recognizes the casual nature of proxy use, often turning a blind eye to their inclusion in non-competitive, informal settings.

Ethical Considerations

The ethical use of proxies treads a fine line. It's generally accepted in casual playgroups, especially when the intent is to test a deck before making a purchase or to enjoy the game without financial strain. The critical factor is transparency and agreement among players. Before using proxies, it's essential to discuss and gain consent from all participants in the game.

Appropriate Use in Casual Play

In casual settings, the use of proxies can enhance the game experience. They allow players to experiment with different strategies and decks without the immediate need to invest in expensive cards. Here are some guidelines for using proxies ethically in casual play:

  • Communication is Key: Always inform your playgroup about the proxies in your deck. Transparency builds trust and ensures everyone is on the same page.
  • Fair Play: Use proxies to level the playing field, not to gain an unfair advantage. Avoid using proxies of excessively rare or powerful cards that could disrupt the game's balance.
  • Respect the Game's Economy: Remember that the trading and collecting aspects are vital to MTG's community. Use proxies as a tool for gameplay, not as a replacement for genuine card collection.
  • Temporary Solution: Consider proxies as a temporary measure. If you find certain cards genuinely enhance your gameplay, aim to acquire them legitimately to support the creators and the game's economy.


Using MTG proxies in casual play can be a practical solution to explore the vast universe of Magic: The Gathering without financial constraints. However, it's crucial to navigate this practice with an understanding of its legal boundaries and ethical implications. By adhering to the community's consensus and maintaining respect for the game and its players, proxies can coexist with the authentic MTG experience, ensuring the game remains accessible and enjoyable for all.

Built by Zac Minner with ☕️ and Scryfall.